[WRTC2006] Selection creteria X previous contets

Sun Jul 29 12:45:37 BRT 2007

MessageHello,  Harry and Roman,
first,  congratulations for the fantastic job!! I think we are going to have a fantastic competition in WRTC 2010.

Secound,  i saw Fabio's(I4UFH) e-mail and your answer...

HI> SO single Band, well some time there no chance to be setted on a
HI> All Band, most of the time , wheather issue, work issue, operator
HI> issue, same shared QTH for 2 SOSB, you cannot have the station
HI> setted for a All Band, and Single Band is the only choice to be
HI> competitive. Can i suggest a Category Factor for the SOSB ??

We are talking about the strongest contesters possible. You can chose
strongest contesters from MAXIMUM categories, which are definitely not
Sinle Band ones.

and sorry friends, but i'm  totally agree with Fabio suggestion. 
In my opinion,  you are putting different thinks at  the same group and you are including contests for the selection criteria (2006, 2007) that are before from these rules. You have  included  first the contests and before change the wrtc rules????? If  you include contests like cqww and cqwpx you must include the categories that you have in these contests.i 
I'm not talking about to change your opinion or your  selection creteria, but don't create a retroative law!
 WRTC is a competion that you have the best operators selected by their results in real world competition, and if you are going to change the wrtc rules,  putting categories in the selection criteria different from the real contets  categories( from the original rules) i think you must  consider the contests for the selection creteria AFTER you publish the  selection creteria rules...not BEFORE...you must give  the world,  to choice a categorie in the competitions  according with wrtc selection creteria.

Best 73

SERGIO -PP5JR
WRTC 2000/2002 competidor
WRTC 2006 President

  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: HRS I4UFH 
  To: wrtc2006 at wrtc2006.com 
  Sent: Saturday, July 28, 2007 11:25 AM
  Subject: Re: [WRTC2006] WRTC2010

  Hi Guys,

  some comments at the rules that I hope we think are still preliminary ..

  Looking at the EU areas there are some anomaly that I think need to be revised.

  Including Italy in direct competition with CT ( CU included ) EA, GD, 9H is not too fair, Italy has no same condition that the most western countries in the list , propagation fade out 1or 2 hours before CU ad G, in any band and will be really no fair competition in this group  .. Best place could be area 4, in a similar geographic place.

  Including SV ( are there also SV9 ? ) in this area seem not to be the right place, from SV condition are pretty worst that YU o EW ..

  Probable a one more area could be a choice to reduce gaps between them and compete in a close field, Europe areas even also US areas probable need to be selective to adjust propagation difference.

  As the VE station from east to west all competitive ? only one team could not be the best choice in a 5 tjme area country as USA !

  SO single Band, well some time there no chance to be setted on a All Band, most of the time , wheather issue, work issue, operator issue, same shared QTH for 2 SOSB, you cannot have the station setted for a All Band, and Single Band is the only choice to be competitive. Can i suggest a Category Factor for the SOSB ??

  Contest Rules are changed, no more IARU zone but Countries ? from DXCC list or as CQWW with WAEDC list too ?

  This change force the developer to create a new WRTC2010 module for this unique event, surely this approach can delight the operators capability in S&P even limited with the low band antennas available, my question is is really needed change contest Rules ??

  Referees : Selected from Team Leader ? Is there the right choice ? The scope of the Judge/Referre is to be an experenced observer and to have the capability to judge,and follow the Team, is the selection is made from the TL, that could be some Judge selection that cannot supply that kind of standard needed to be one of them.

  Hope that an open discussion coul help to improve the rules of the next amazing experience ... WRTC2010 !

  73 de I4UFH

    ----- Original Message ----- 
    From: Andy Cook, G4PIQ 
    To: wrtc2006 at wrtc2006.com 
    Sent: Saturday, July 28, 2007 2:22 PM
    Subject: Re: [WRTC2006] WRTC2010

    Do IARU HQ station entries count as MM entries subject to the rule of no more than 2 members of the team submitting a score?

    73,

    Andy, G4PIQ
      -----Original Message-----
      From: wrtc2006-bounces at wrtc2006.com [mailto:wrtc2006-bounces at wrtc2006.com] On Behalf Of Roman Thomas
      Sent: 27 July 2007 09:37
      To: wrtc2006 at list.wrtc2006.com
      Subject: [WRTC2006] WRTC2010
      Importance: High

      Dear friends,
      please find attached WRTC-2010 Selection Criteria and Preliminary Contest rules prepared by WRTC-2010 OC and
      confirmed by WRTC-SC.
      73's RZ3AA  

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

    _______________________________________________
    WRTC2006 mailing list
    WRTC2006 at wrtc2006.com
    http://list.wrtc2006.com/mailman/listinfo/wrtc2006

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

  _______________________________________________
  WRTC2006 mailing list
  WRTC2006 at wrtc2006.com
  http://list.wrtc2006.com/mailman/listinfo/wrtc2006
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://list.wrtc2006.com/pipermail/wrtc2006/attachments/20070729/6f16f213/attachment.html 